Following the main conference, Europeana convened the inaugural meeting of National Libraries (and equivalent consortium organisations) who are currently working directly with Wikidata and its underlying software Wikibase. This event was organised by our Wikimedia liaison Liam Wyatt and hosted by our partners the National Library of Sweden. Liam updates us here on the meeting content.
At the forefront of innovation
As Wikidata becomes an increasingly large, densely connected, web of linked data, the cultural heritage sector is leveraging the platform more and more. None more so than national libraries, who have been at the forefront of innovations. Thirty institutional representatives participated in this meeting from three continents.
The meeting began with a series of short demonstration talks from institutions already working with Wikidata and Wikibase in-house. These are notable not only for the variety of activities undertaken and the successes already being reported from these young projects, but also for the fact that until recently, they have all been happening largely in isolation with limited knowledge-sharing.
Demonstrations of projects currently underway were given by:
- Llyfrgell Genedlaethol Cymru/National Library of Wales (slides)
- Kansalliskirjasto/National Library of Finland (slides)
- Bibliothèque Nationale de France/National Library of France (slides)
- Deutsche Nationalbibliothek/National Library of Germany (slides)
- Library of Congress – USA (slides)
- Linked Data for Production project (LD4P) – USA (slides)
- OCLC – International (slides)
- Kungliga biblioteket/National LIbrary of Sweden (slides)
The new director of the National Library of Sweden, Karin Grönvall, on quite literally her first day at the job, also took the time to greet us.
Heading into the meeting, approximately 40% of the attendees reported that their institution had already undertaken export of their own information into Wikidata. Afterwards, more than 50% reported that as a specific result of what they’d learned they would now investigate undertaking further exports; over 60% also reported they would now be investigating the Wikibase software for in-house use; and 100% of responses received stated a high satisfaction with the day’s usefulness for their institution.
‘I found it incredibly helpful to learn more about the Wikidata projects that other institutions are working on, areas in which we could potentially collaborate, and to get a better idea of the future directions of Wikidata and Wikibase to inform our project plans.’
- participant survey feedback
What’s next: the roadmap
Following the initial presentations, the meeting moved on to discussions informing – and also getting valuable feedback about – the ‘roadmap’: the forthcoming developments in Wikidata and Wikibase.
This began with a section on the work of the Structured Data on Commons project – which is bringing the power of linked data to WikimediaCommons – and was followed by in-depth discussions of two specific areas of Wikibase software development that are common requests for libraries: permissions and federation.
The former request, permissions, refers to the nuanced read and/or write permissions that cultural institutions would like to provide when managing their own catalogue infrastructure on Wikibase. While in Wikidata the general principle is that everyone can see and edit any part of any item, for libraries this might not be sufficient. Potential outcomes include: designating certain users with advanced permissions to edit specific sections of items, or certain items in entirety; and making certain items or sections of those items visible only to particular users. Having a ‘second opinion’ check-function before a change is published was also discussed. These features might be necessary, for example, in catalogue management where some library staff have the right to edit bibliographic metadata, while other designated staff might have the right to view particularly sensitive information about acquisitions.
The latter request, federation, refers to the principle that multiple Wikibase instances can work with each other – each containing different information, but being able to sync elements so as not to duplicate effort and in order to propagate up-to-date information. However, as Lydia Pintscher – Wikidata product manager – explained to the group, everyone believes federation is a good idea, however everyone also has a different understanding of what it would mean in practice! In the meeting we talked through various practical options of federated Wikibase including but not limited to: shared properties but local items; shared items but local properties; and shared querying.
Strategic papers of interest
Almost simultaneously to this event, the Wikidata team published four strategy papers, including the high-level vision, and a specific paper discussing the future of the Wikibase ecosystem. This latter report provides the specific motivation for why the cultural sector – particularly national libraries – are investigating Wikibase:
‘Wikibase is useful for any kind of heterogeneous data, where connections between the data play an important role. This is relevant for all kinds of fields, starting from (digital) humanities to life sciences. Recently we have seen a lot of activity from the GLAM sector. […] Seven national libraries, among them Germany and France, have run substantial pilots, and libraries from seven more countries have communicated interest in evaluating or using Wikibase or Wikidata as a platform for creating or participating in linked data work for the sector. [...] So far, we have mainly been asking institutions to donate content to us. By fostering a Wikibase Ecosystem, we also have something significant and useful to give back to institutions. This kind of mutually beneficial relationship would strengthen our existing bonds with institutions, and create new partnerships with institutions we haven't reached yet.’
- Strategy for the Wikibase Ecosystem, pages 3, 8
This strategy is consistent with the Association of Research Libraries extensively researched April 2019 Whitepaper discussing the use of Wikibase and Wikidata in the library context.
For more information about any of the discussions during the Stockholm meeting, please consult the comprehensive notes taken during the day itself.